samedi 18 décembre 2010

# ARCHITECTURES OF JOY. A spinozist reading of Parent/Virilio and Arakawa/Gins’ architecture

Site of Reversible Destiny - Yoro Park by Arakawa & Madeline Gins


A spinozist reading of Parent/Virilio and Arakawa/Gins’ architecture
By Léopold Lambert (December 2010)

In the middle of the XVIIth century, Baruch Spinoza revolutionized theology by proposing a tremendous change in the definition of God. From the classic transcendental vision of a God creator, he introduced an immanent vision of God creature. Some architects might stop their reading of Spinoza’s Ethics here and consider the whole theory as an external element from their practice. However, this immanent theology envisions the world in such a way that architecture can creates itself based on this vision and celebrates it in composing what we will call, an architecture of joy. The first part of this short essay will attempt to concisely envision Spinoza’s Ethics, the second will present the difference between joyful affects and sad affects, and the third and last one will try to elaborate relationships between this philosophy and the architectural projects designed by Claude Parent and Paul Virilio in the 1960’s on the one hand, and those built by Arakawa and Madeline Gins in the last ten years on the other hand.

Spinoza envisions God as the infinite substance composing the universe. This substance is an infinite amount of infinitely small parts which develop external relations with each other and thus compose bodies. The ability of those bodies to maintain the effort of persisting in their own beings is called conatus and composes the essence of things. Those bodies have then the ability to encounter and affect each other and thus increasing or decreasing their power of action. That being stated, we can observe that Spinoza is not only a rebel against religion but also against the paradigmatic philosophy of his century; the Cartesian philosophy. In fact, in the second book of his Ethics, he demonstrates the following proposition: The Human mind does not perceive any external body as existing, except through the ideas of the modifications of its own body. In other words, a mind knows itself only via the encounter with other things which is in complete contradiction with Descartes’ I think, therefore I am , in which a mind knows itself by thinking. Spinoza, on the contrary could have states something like “I encounter, therefore I am.”

From there, Spinoza distinguishes four modes of perception in his Treatise on the Improvement of the Understanding . In order to focus on the proposed topic here, we won’t even evoke the first one, “arising from hearsay” that is negligible. In fact, in his class for the University of Vincennes about Spinoza, Gilles Deleuze – who appears between the lines in this essay- does not even talk about this first mode of perception that he personally calls kinds of knowledge. Those three remaining modes of perception are establishes as following:

- The first one is empirical. It implies only the experience of shock between the extensive parts of respective bodies and thus provides what Spinoza calls inadequate ideas. Deleuze, in order to illustrate this mode, uses the example of the wave. In the first mode of perception/knowledge, one can only experience the shock of the wave against his body. In other words, it provokes a knowledge of effects without a knowledge of causes.
- The second one is both empirical and rational. It involves the composition of relations between the bodies. In the illustration of the wave, one can position his body in such a way that the relations of the wave compose in a harmonious way with the relation of one’s body.
- The third one is strictly rational. It implies a perception of the essence of a thing or, following what we wrote earlier about the essence, the understanding of the mechanisms of perpetuation of a body in its being. It is indeed an understanding of causes and this way can be defined as adequate ideas.

From there, the purpose of this essay becomes probably clearer and one can distinguish the role that the second mode of perception can play in architecture. However, it is still too early in this text to evoke this question as the Ethics itself has not been yet deployed.

The first part has in fact established Spinoza’s theology/cosmology and the different modes of perception of it; nevertheless, the second part needs to develop veritably what makes Spinoza calls his book Ethics. In fact, one more reason for his Cherem from the Jewish Community is that he establishes a fundamental distinction between a religious moral and an individual ethics. The good versus evil both determined transcendentally are replaced by the good versus the bad which are, on the other hand, determined by the accordance or the discordance of relations between parts composing bodies.

As Deleuze explains in his class, when I have an encounter such that the relation of the body which modifies me, which acts on me is combined with my own relation, […] my power of acting is increased . This encounter that increases the power of acting is defined by Spinoza as being good and he calls it Joy. As a corollary, any encounter that tends to destroy the relations of one’s body is considered as bad for this same body and thus is called sadness. In the same way Spinoza decided to keep the same terminology (God) than religion in order to show the revolutionary content of his philosophy, he uses the creationist religious example of the Original Sin in his demonstration, in order to deactivate what used to be the paradigm of the religious moral. He affirms that Adam did not do an evil act when he ate the apple, but rather he did a bad act as the relations of the apple were not composing well with his own relations. What is described in the Bible as a divine interdiction to eat the apple is nothing else than Adam’s instinct that the apple may be poisonous for his body.

Since joy results from the harmony of relations between two bodies, joy can be said to be the motor of the persistence of the parts in their being. We have already seen that this persistence is called essence by Spinoza but it also matches with the notion of desire also called appetite. This notion is central here, as it implies the action that is required for the concerned architecture to be activated and to be legitimately considered as Architectures of Joy.

Those principles of Spinoza’s Ethics being expressed, we can now begin to evoke the two architectures we proposed to investigate in this essay.
The first one is the work of the association between the two French architects, Claude Parent and Paul Virilio between 1963 and 1969 under the name of Architecture Principe. In 1964, they established an architectural manifesto that can be summarized by an action of tilting the ground that replaces the paradigmatic assemblage of horizontal plans with vertical ones. They call it, The Oblique Function.

Explanatory diagram by Claude Parent in Architecture principe : 1966 und 1996 . [Besançon] : Les Ed. de l'Imprimeur, 2000.

The previous diagram illustrates the effect of the tilted surface on the body. If we apply a Spinozist reading on it, we can observe that the first mode of perception is necessarily occurring as gravity forces the bodies’ parts to interact with the architectural surface’s parts. However, in the difference of architectures which proceed only with flat floors, in the Oblique Function, gravity imposes an additional effect on the bodies, a directionality. In fact, any movement of the body in any direction will exercise on it, a degree of acceleration. This acceleration will be negative if the body attempts to climb up the surface and it will be positive if the same body attempts to go down the slope.

If we accept to consider as negligible -for the sake of this argument- the effects of a flat surface on the body, we can obviously not do the same for the Oblique Function’s effects. In fact, a negative acceleration imposed on the body creates a fatigue on the body whereas a positive one triggers an exhilaration. One could thus hastily argue that only half of the potential movements on this surface provide a Spinozist joy when the other half provokes sadness. However, this affirmation would be inaccurate as the body in action while conquering –we use the word conquest here in the same way that Deleuze talks about the conquest of colors by Gauguin and Van Gogh - the slope is expressing its power of existence. This last argument is the one that lead us to think that comfort and joy are not synonyms if not veritably antonyms.

In that sense, the Oblique Function, in its experience, requires the exercise of the second mode of perception. On this tilted surface, a body can only persist in its being if it manages to compose harmoniously its relations with the relations of this surface. That is how we can affirm that Claude Parent and Paul Virilio manage to create an Architecture of Joy in the Spinozist meaning of joy. The Oblique Function, being only a manifesto, it is interesting to observe the work –mostly by Parent- that has been built based on those principles:

- The Villa Drusch in Versailles (1963)_
- Sainte Bernadette Church in Nevers (1966)
- The French Pavilion at the Venice Biennale (1970)
- Claude Parent’s apartment in Neuilly sur Seine (1973)

French Pavilion at the Venice Biennale (1970) designed by Claude Parent

The second architecture on which we propose to apply a Spinozist reading is the work of Arakawa and Madeline Gins. In fact, despite the fact that their work has been comfortably categorized by critics as having more to do with art than with architecture in the same way than many radical architects, their production is probably the best achievement of a Spinozist architecture.

In order to illustrate this point, we have to start by evoking the notion of the Architectural Body developed by Arakawa and Gins. In fact, in their research of an interaction between the human body and the architectural environment, they establish this notion as a symbiosis of those two entities. The Architectural Body is thus an entity in which the second mode of perception is continuous. Placed in a state of disequilibrium as in Arakawa and Gins’ architecture, the human body keeps re-harmonizing its parts in relation with the architectural parts and thus develops a conscience of its direct environment. Via this process of harmonization, the body learns and becomes both stronger and more skillful.

Reversible Destiny Lofts – Mitaka by Arakawa and Madeline Gins. Photograph by Masatako Nakano.

That leads us to the main purpose of such an architecture for Arakawa and Madeline Gins which consists in a adamant refusal to death. In accordance with the XVIIIth century French physiologist Xavier Bichat who stated that life is the ensemble of functions that resist death , they undertake to architecturally train the body against the continuous degradation of human tissues.

One could not be more wrong to associate this enterprise with the Modernist belief for potential healing characteristics own by architecture. Indeed, what Arakawa and Gins calls Reversible Destiny is an absolute refusal towards the modernist comfort that triggers a process of weakening for the body and decreases its power. On the contrary their architecture challenges the body, put it in danger and leaves it without any other alternative than to react to this delicate situation. In this regard, this architecture is profoundly anti-paternalist and own some clear emancipative characteristics. It releases the exact same Spinozist freedom, when he writes A thing is called free which exists from the necessity of its nature alone, and is determined to act by itself alone .

Spinoza describes death as the change of belonging of a body’s parts to another body. The parts do not persist in their being anymore and they start to populate one or several other bodies. The goal of Arakawa and Gins is therefore to maintain this persistence as long as possible via a continuous conquest of joy as we have been defining it earlier in this essay. Describing the condition offers by the Bioscleave House (Life Span Extending Villa), Madeline Gins has this evocative sentence: Everyday, you are practicing how not to die.

Bioscleave House by Arakawa and Madeline Gins

In the Proposition II of the Book III in his Ethics, Spinoza writes no one has hitherto laid down the limits to the powers of the body, that is, no one has as yet been taught by experience what the body can accomplish solely by the laws of nature, in so far as she is regarded as extension . This way, he asks a fundamental question which can be formulated this way: What can a body do? The question that the Oblique Function and the Reversible Destiny ask is not different in any way. Acknowledging their common ignorance with Spinoza, those radical architects attempt to create an environment dedicated to the Spinozist Joy, only condition for the beginning of an answer to this question.

74 commentaires:

etc. a dit…

Great! I find them important in their beingness even more than as ideas though.

Have A&G made diagrams, or given other forms of visual/textual informations about what, how and why they used in their design for everyday-living?
It would be great to know their science (if there is one)- in the forms, the "scapes" and the use of colors.

Léopold Lambert a dit…

For having a bit explored four (The Architectural Body, We have decided not to die, The mechanisms of meaning and Sites of Reversible Destiny) of their numerous books, the most eloquent as far as architecture is concerned might be We have decided not to die, the 1997 catalog for the Guggenheim. In it you have plethora of diagrams, experiments and other spatial simulations of their architecture.

lys_ a dit…

I find this really interesting! someway unusual but clear reading of parent/virilio oblique function. I think they represent a radical critical approach to euclidean/cartesian space and, as you underline here, also cartesian thought. Deleuzian before Deleuze. However I think they meant to achieve this space-body revolution more through the study of every-day living, I would say of postural and psychophysical effects of the oblique, than through merely formal study. Form seems to be a consequence, this is why I think A&G are, more than others, true followers of Parent/Virilio.

Anonyme a dit…

Very intereresting reading. thx


xl pharmacy a dit…

Architecture that presents itself procedurally to people helps them take note of their architectural bodies. Architecture as usual could not care less about the architectural body, sadly enough

luan a dit…

I love the loft idea. I didn't expect that it can be designed like that. Wow~ its incredibly great! Thanks for sharing this! Really great architectures.

Irish from chambre ado 

Anonyme a dit…

buy xanax online forum buy xanax online with insurance - can take 2mg xanax once

Anonyme a dit…

buy ambien online ambien cr cost without insurance - ambien sleepwalking lawsuit

Anonyme a dit…

buy diazepam buy diazepam usa no prescription - diazepam 10mg dosage

Anonyme a dit…

buy diazepam online can i buy diazepam - diazepam online new zealand

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online xanax partydrug - xanax bars 10 mg

Anonyme a dit…

lorazepam no prescription ativan side effects copd - can get high ativan

Anonyme a dit…

ativan no prescription can you overdose ativan - ativan used

Anonyme a dit…

buy diazepam diazepam 5 mg and pregnancy - diazepam standard dosage

Anonyme a dit…

buy ambien online ambien buy online usa - rebound insomnia from ambien

Anonyme a dit…

soma drug carisoprodol injection - carisoprodol 350 mg dosage

Anonyme a dit…

buy generic soma soma usa online pharmacy - carisoprodol 350 mg looks like

Anonyme a dit…

buy diazepam online order valium online no prescription - where to buy valium in the uk

Anonyme a dit…

zolpidem 10 mg ambien cr yellow part - ambien online forum

Anonyme a dit…

soma drug carisoprodol 350 mg recreational use - carisoprodol kidney disease

Anonyme a dit…

buy valium online 800 mg valium - valium effects neurotransmitters

Anonyme a dit…

buy soma generic carisoprodol 5 panel drug test - soma drug 350 mg

Anonyme a dit…

buy ambien online ambien cr headaches - ambien and alcohol withdrawal

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online xanax dosage low - xanax controlled substance schedule

Anonyme a dit…

tramadol online buy tramadol no prescription online - tramadol 50mg tablets get you high

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg compared to percocet - tramadol online order

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol for toothache - tramadol generic for ultram

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol cod tramadol addiction long term use - tramadol 100mg effects

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal tiredness - buy tramadol online in usa

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online xanax dosage muscle relaxant - what does a 2mg xanax look like

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online buy tramadol overnight delivery - buy tramadol from usa

Anonyme a dit…

generic xanax xanax pills gg 258 - xanax side effects paranoia

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online different types xanax pills - .25 mg xanax and alcohol

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online cheap generic xanax online - xanax effects bluelight

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online best place buy tramadol online - tramadol 100

Anonyme a dit…

xanax online xanax drug for sleep - where to buy xanax in australia

Anonyme a dit…

buy cialis no prescription generic cialis doesn't work - cialis mechanism of action

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol purchase online no prescription - buy tramadol online florida

Anonyme a dit…

tramadol 100mg tramadol for dogs how much - tramadol hcl high

Anonyme a dit… best way buy tramadol online - can i get high on 50 mg tramadol

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online buy tramadol online usa - tramadol overdose antidote

Anonyme a dit… order tramadol online mastercard - tramadol 20mg

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online mastercard overnight tramadol 50 mg much - tramadol mg

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol boompanjang blogspot buy tramadol online - buy tramadol medication

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol 50mg 100ct - tramadol for cats

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online cod ultram tramadol overdose - tramadol 20mg

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol usa tramadol dose vet - buy tramadol usa pharmacy

Anonyme a dit…

buy tramadol online tramadol hcl paracetamol - tramadol 50 mg for ultram

Anonyme a dit…

xanax no prescription online prozac vs xanax for anxiety - xanax zyprexa

alicetaylor a dit…

This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much


safegenericrx a dit…

Nice blog thanks for sharing this informative blog with us.
cheap Tapentadol 100 mg USA

Maria a dit…

Tramadol is used similarly to codeine, to treat moderate to moderately severe pain. Tramadol is somewhat pharmacologically similar to levorphanol (albeit with much lower μ-agonism), as both opioids are also NMDA-antagonists which also have SNRI activity (other such opioids to do the same are dextropropoxyphene (Darvon) & M1-like molecule tapentadol (Nucynta, a new synthetic atypical opioid made to mimic the agonistic properties of tramadol's metabolite, M1(O-Desmethyltramadol). Tramadol is also molecularly similar to venlafaxine (Effexor) and has similar SNRI effects, with antinociceptive effects also observed.

Buy Tramadol in USA | Buy Tramadol Online

Ankit Sethi a dit…

you could Buy Soma 500mg pills Online if you have suffering from pain.

Anonyme a dit…

Since you’ve planned to buy Tramadol online, you must be aware of the fact that the drug works for both acute and chronic pain.

Cheap fioricet online a dit…

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I appreciate your writing skills.Keep up good work.

Evaaide a dit…

Hi there,
Thank you so much for the post you do and also I like your post, we are the No. one approved Online Pharmacy to be offering an excellent chance for you to Adderall 20mg order top-quality Adderall 20mg here with no RX required and get overnight delivery 100% safe with high convenience in the whole USA.
Click here for READ MORE......

buytramadolonline a dit…

Thanks for sharing such type of Blog. we are also providing services like buy tramadol online.
Tramadol is a drug which is prescribed for the treatment of lack of attention (ADHD) and sleepiness (Narcolepsy). However, as and as the effects of the drug start wearing off, a person becomes what he was before he started taking the medication. Anyone can buy easily these drugs.
buy tramadol online
Tramadol 100mg
Tramadol 325mg
Tramadol 50mg
Tramadol 200mg

Generic Medz Online a dit…

Our online pharmacy specializes in the distribution of various prescription without need for a prescription.
We sell medications ranging from ADHD, weight loss, opiates, sex tablets , anti anxiety ,Hepatitis C, Demerol, pharmaceutical powders, CBD oil etc
Payment and shipping are all secured

Buy Xanax Online
Buy Adderall Online
Buy Tramadol Online
Buy Norco Online
Buy Soma Online
Buy Ambien Online
Buy Vicodin Online
Buy Percocet Online
Buy Hydrocodone Online
Buy Green Xanax Online
Buy Yellow Xanax Online
Buy Blue Xanax Online
Buy White Xanax online
Buy Pink Xanax Online
Buy Purple Xanax Online
Buy Subutex Online a dit…

buy ativan online

can you buy ativan online

order ativan online

ativan for sale

ativan online sale

buy ativan tablet

buy ativan without prescription

where to buy ativan

ativan online uk

lorazepam for sale

lorazepam online canada

ativan online

buy ativan no prescription

buy ativan online uk

how to buy ativan

lorazepam online prescription

where to get ativan

ativan for sale canada

ativan in canada

buy ativan 1mg

buy ativan online reviews

buy ativan usa

buy xanax tablets online uk

can i buy lorazepam online uk

how can i get ativan

lorazepam online

order ativan online canada

order ativan online legally

ativan 2mg buy online

ativan 2mg online order

ativan canada

ativan from mexico

ativan over the counter

ativan tablet for sale

buy alprazolam online australia

buy alprazolam online india

buy alprazolam uk

buy ambien uk

buy ativan online australia

buy ativan online overnight

buy ativan overnight

buy cheap tramadol uk

buy cheap valium online us

buy diazepam online

buy pfizer xanax online us

buy valium cheap online us

buy xanax 2mg california

buy xanax us

buy zolpidem online uk

buying xanax online reviews 2017

can you buy generic xanax online

can you buy xanax

can you get ativan over the counter

can you get lorazepam over the counter

cheap generic valium online

cheap zolpidem online

cost of ativan in canada

diazepam for sale online us

Way Right Meds a dit…

Buy Ritalin Online Archives - Ambien Generic

Ritalin is used to treat attention deficit disorder (ADD), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

ritalin buy online

buy ritalin 5 mg online

buy ritalin 10mg online

buy 20 mg ritalin online

buy ritalin online

buy generic ritalin online

Way Right Meds a dit…


Ambien is a medicine that contains zolpidem. You can buy ambien online to treat insomnia in adults. If a person is having problems sleeping or he/she cannot stay asleep, ambien can help them address this condition

Buy ambien Online

Buy Ambien Generic

Buy ambien 5mg

Buy Ambien10mg

Mexicanpills a dit…

useful info.. Thanks for sharing.

Tarmadol 200 mg Online

Way Right Meds a dit…

Adderall | Buy Adderall online | order Adderall online for treating ADHD | Adderall 7.5mg | Adderall side effects | Adderall pills

Buy Adderall 7.5 mg Online
buy Adderall online,
BUY Adderall 10 mg Online
BUY Adderall 20 mg Online
BUY Adderall 30 mg Online
Buy Adderall - XR 10 mg

Way Right Meds a dit…

Call Now For Buy Anxiety / Pain Releiver Medicines at exceptionally modest cost as compare to other seller: +1-850-424-1335

Buy Hydrocodone Online
Buy Percocet Online
Buy Xanax Online
Order Hydrocodone High
Buy Tramadol 100 mg
Buy Green Xanax Bars

Willamm James a dit…

Thanks for writing this article such a helps to all people for our health related problems like muscle pain, chronic pain, or joint pain and so on...
Click Here
Buy soma 350mg online
Order Soma 500mg cash on delivery in cheap price
Buy Soma (Carisoprodol) Online COD
Order Soma 500mg Online COD with PayPal and Credit/Debit Card

pharmaceuticals a dit…

percocet for sale
percocet for sale usa
percocet for sale canada
order percocet uk
buy viagra online uk
buy cheap viagra online
order viagra 50mg 100mg online
where to buy viagra online usa
Buy Viagra 50mg 100mg Online
order hydrocodone online uk and usa
where to buy hydrocodone online
best quality hydrocodone for sale
purchase hydrocodone online
Buy Hydrocodone Online
best quality Roxicodone for sale online
where to buy roxicodone online
Roxicodone for sale online
purchase Roxicodone online usa
Buy Roxicodone Online
Sour Diesel Shatter
Afghan Kush
White Widow
where to order OG Kush online

Robert liam a dit…

Are you looking for an effective medication for pain management? You are at the right place. Here we will discuss one of the most talked-about pain management medicine in the world: TapenTadol.

You can Buy TapenTadol Online at highly discounted prices from our online reputed pharmacy

Visit Some Important Links....

TapenTadol 100mg Cash on Delivery
Get TapenTadol COD
How to Buy TapenTadol 100mg online
Tapentadol for pain relief
TapenTadol Without Prescription
Where to order TapenTadol online

wannaparty a dit…

Thanks for important information; we wanna party is the best party supplier in India. We provide birthday party decorations, Twinkle Twinke Little Star, fashion supplies, Halloween Party Supplies, etc.
Feel free to contact us anytime.

Steave Roger a dit…

Thanks for posting this web log, I'm terribly affected along with your web log and it's helpful on behalf of me and alternative. it's really nice and meaningful. You really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them useful information. Many people who take Xanax recreationally, or without a prescription, describe the feeling as sedating or calming.
Xanax belongs to the benzodiazepine family and is a kind of anti-anxiety medication which works by decreasing the abnormal excitement in the brain. It directly acts upon the central nervous system in order to produce a calming effect. The doctor guides and prescribes the necessary dose according to the patient’s medical history and the ongoing treatment. Thus before buying Xanax online do keep in mind such precautions relating to the medication of Xanax. It becomes of more important care to take precautions as you can buy Xanax without prescription.

Buy Xanax Online
Buy Xanax Online without prescription
Buy Xanax Online with overnight delivery
Get Xanax Online

Emma Mackey a dit…

Tramadol is prescribed for pain relief. If you are suffering from chronic pain, you can Buy tramadol (Ol-Tram) 200mg, 100mg, 50mg tablets online for managing moderate to severe pain.

Buy Tramadol Online
Pain O Soma 350mg
Tapentadol 100mg Online
Buy Tramadol 200mg

Olivia Smith a dit…

To Treat insomnia that is a sleeping problem
Buy Zopiclone Online at a low price.

Elinathomas a dit…

It offers excellent security with many benefits. If you are planning to create a Gmail account, don't hesitate to create it and easy to use. Some of Google's Gmail is listed below in this article. Here you will find all the details to set up your Gmail account and solve your Gmail account related problem all at once. Gmail Nummer

PillsOnlineRx a dit…

Beautifully written. For successful and safe abortion at home Buy MTP Kit online USA from

Women And Health a dit…

I appreciate you sharing the thorough information. a truly excellent post.
Order abortion pill